Banking Exchange Magazine Logo

Shareholder activism building in banking industry

New tactics, new targets—beware the “wolfpack”

SNL Financial is the premier provider of breaking news, financial data, and expert analysis on business sectors critical to the global economy. This article originally appeared on the subscriber side of SNL Financial's website. SNL Financial is the premier provider of breaking news, financial data, and expert analysis on business sectors critical to the global economy. This article originally appeared on the subscriber side of SNL Financial's website.

By Nathan Stovall, SNL Financial staff writer

Advisers see shareholder activism growing in the banking industry.

A group of dedicated activists have targeted banks for years, but the number of funds engaging in activism in the industry is growing and supported by successful campaigns. Sluggish economic growth and low rate environment has challenged bank profitability and made institutions not earning their cost of capital ripe targets for activists. Those funds now receive backing from proxy adviser firms as well, bringing the support of large institutional shareholders.

"Activists are certainly going to be part of the banking scene, for the next few years," Gerard Cassidy, managing director and head of U.S. bank equity strategy at RBC Capital Markets, said at the recent SNL Bank M&A Symposium.

The analyst said banks that cannot earn their cost of capital are most likely to be targets of activist campaigns. If a bank is unable to improve and consistently reports a 5% to 6% return on equity when its cost of capital is 9% or 10%, an activist will surface, he said.

Activists have allies today

Those activists no longer have to fight on their own. Sandler O'Neill & Partners principal Emmett Daly said at the SNL event that advisory firm ISS has recently been in favor of activists in the bank group and not management teams. The shift has brought an entire new universe of investors into the activist fray, Daly said.

Day said it is now fair game for large funds like Wellington Management, Vanguard Group, and Fidelity Management to vote with activists and not side with management because ISS is backing them.

Daly pointed to the pending sale of Metro Bancorp Inc. to F.N.B. Corp. announced over the summer as an example of the recent shift. In just nine months, Metro went from having no activists involved in its stock to having activists like Basswood Capital Management LLC, PL Capital Group, and a number of other investors supporting their campaign owning a large block of the company's shares. He said there are 10 to 15 hedge funds in market that once "one of their buddies gets into your stock, it's a waterfall."

"I don't think anyone is too strong," Daly said. "They are extremely sophisticated these days."

Michael Schechter, a managing director in the financial institutions group at JPMorgan, said at the SNL event that activists are becoming increasingly comfortable with financial institutions. Schechter highlighted a number of recent activist campaigns in the bank space, noting that Trian Fund Management LP has targeted Bank of New York Mellon Corp. and State Street Corp., while Greenlight has gone after Citizens Financial Group Inc. and CIT Group Inc. Basswood has been even more prevalent, targeting First California Bank, Banc of California Inc., Hudson Valley Holding Corp., Synovus Financial Corp., Metro, and most recently Astoria Financial Corp. A handful of those institutions ultimately sold.

Schechter said activists have not yet agitated a company that is performing as planned. He said the groups look at the potential of downside risk and consider the possibility of the company selling. For instance, he noted that Astoria, Sterling Bancshares Inc., Hudson Valley all had more than one potential acquirer.

Targets no longer just the small players

Activists in the bank space have historically focused on small, underperforming banks. More recently, though, they have targeted larger regional players. Longtime activist PL Capital recently disclosed that it is in the process of forming a new fund that will focus on banks with assets between $3 billion and $75 billion as it hopes to build on its past success. Through Aug. 31, 2015, PL Capital had produced a five-year net return of 151.1%, compared to a 104.8% return produced by the SNL Micro Cap U.S. Bank & Thrift Index during the same period.

Notwithstanding PL Capital's new focus, some observers see activism in the bank space as a limited event, in no small part due to the restrictions the Bank Holding Company Act places on ownership in a single bank's stock. Investors are often limited to owning a 9.9% voting stake in the company if they want to exert influence and avoid having to register as a bank holding company.  

Beware the “wolfpack”

Still, Sullivan & Cromwell LLP Senior Chairman H. Rodgin Cohen believes that the threat of shareholder activists has not been fully appreciated in the banking industry. He said at the SNL event that close to 500 funds have engaged in shareholder activism over the last 18 months and have raised $150 billion in funds dedicated to the strategy.

Cohen noted that activists and their supporters can quickly pile into a company's stock in a "wolfpack attack" and not be seen as acting in concert. He called for the Federal Reserve, OCC, and FDIC to collaborate and develop a clear policy statement, outlining the rules for activists investing alongside one another.

Cohen said those investors should receive the same level of scrutiny as bank investors participating in a large recapitalization. Those investors often face a searching inquiry to determine if they are acting in concert. Any group acting in concert could face the limitations laid out in the Bank Holding Company Act.

Cohen believes such a clarification is necessary because a number of factors have converged to make shareholder activists more prepared to take on banks of all shapes, sizes, and performance records. For instance, the veteran attorney noted that Trian took a 2% stake in BNY Mellon and criticized the company, which prompted it to give a board seat to the activist. He said the move didn't prevent another activist hedge fund called Marcato Capital Management LP from taking a 1% stake in BNY Mellon and publicly calling for significant changes at the company.

"It is true that only a small minority of banks will be subject to an activist challenge. But if your bank is one of those, it is no solace that you are a statistical anomaly," Cohen said. "Every bank board should engage in education and advance preparation regarding activists."

Nathan Stovall is a senior editor and columnist with SNL Financial. The views and opinions expressed in this piece are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of SNL.

This article originally appeared on SNL Financial’s website under the title, "Shareholder activism building in the banking industry.”

SNL Financial

SNL Financial, now part of S&P Global Market Intelligence, is the premier provider of breaking news, financial data, and expert analysis on business sectors critical to the global economy: Banking, Insurance, Financial Services, Real Estate, Energy, Media & Communications and Metals & Mining. SNL's business intelligence service provides investment professionals, from leading Wall Street institutions to top corporate management, with access to an in-depth electronic database, available online and updated 24/7. This article originally appeared on the subscriber side of SNL Financial's website in slightly different form and appears on as part of a cooperative venture. Each week a selected SNL article will be brought to our readers. Click here to learn more about SNL Financial and to obtain a free trial subscription. 

back to top


About Us

Connect With Us